Level Advancement

This is the 22nd in a continuing series of articles, which reedits house rules for Holmes Basic D&D from 40-year-old game club newsletters. Mentions of house rules are in bold text and followed by a [bracketed category designator].

For rules category descriptions and more about the newsletters, see “About the Reedition of Phenster’s.” For an index of articles, see Coming Up in “Pandemonium Society House Rules.”

Phenster’s Pandemonium Society House Rules is a work of fiction. Names, characters, businesses, events, incidents, and newsletters are either products of the author’s imagination or are used in a fictitious manner. Any resemblance to actual persons, living or dead, or actual events is pure coincidence.

A note on the cover page near the closing staple of Paradigm Lost #2 (November 1980) instructs the subscriber to “REMOVE STAPLE WITH CARE . . . CENTERFOLD INSIDE!!!!” Phenster teases us further in the editorial column “From the Amanuensis”:

We have a special "centerfold" treat in this issue for all you little demons of the Pandemonium Society. An assortment of tables (that go with a piece by Hazard about characters past 3RD LEVEL) are arranged by themselves on one side of 6 pages with a drawing of a siren (sorry, none of our photographs came out). All you have to do is unfold the pages (you were careful with the staple, right?) and paste/tape them onto cardboard that you can fold in threes. Add a few more tables of your own devising for your own custom Referee Screen!

Our subscriber A. J. Postlethwaite seems to have heeded the first instruction but failed to carry out the second. Only two tiny holes indicate the staple’s one-time presence. The center pages are intact.

I reproduce Hazard’s tables within each house rule below.

Level Advancement

Players in the Great Halls of Pandemonium progressed beyond 3rd level over the summer. Since school started I've been juggling calculus, chemistry, and trying to decide how to manage experience points, spells, attack matrices, and so on. (Thank Crom for study hall!) My first idea was to make the switch to AD&D like everybody else. After a lot of reading and much thinking though, I decided the "advanced" rules are too complicated for what they give the game. I looked at the old rules too, but frankly, it's a big mess. They just kept adding on to the system until it became a golem of rules. Eventually, I made up some stuff, inspired by both the old and the new. I tried not to change any numbers (hit tables, saving throw matrices, spells, etc.) from levels 1-3 in the Basic book, so any characters rolled-up from that book are still valid in the Great Halls campaign.

Necessary Experience for Higher Levels

Double the amount you need every level, as in the Basic rules, until you get to 8th level. The total amount you need to get to 8th level is what you need to get from 8th to 9th and for every level higher. Fighters need 4,000 to attain 3rd level, 8,000 for 4th, etc. . . They need 128,000 to reach 8th level. Then they need 128,000 more XP to get to 9th level (256,000), then 128,000 more for 10th level (384,000), and so on.

You get normal HD + bonus h.p. for CON at every level gain through 9th level. After that, you don’t get more HD or bonus h.p. You just get +1 h.p. per level except fighters, which get +2.

Magic Spells

Clerics

Clerics get first and second level spells through their faith at 2nd and 4th level, respectively. Third through fifth level spells (gained at 5th, 6th, and 7th level) are delivered to them by divine intermediaries, like angels and such, while sixth and seventh level spells are given by the deity itself. Clerics can cast these spells at 9th and 12th levels.

Clerics get another first and second level spell at every other level after the first spell. Third through fifth, they get every 3 levels, and sixth and seventh every 4 levels.

Magic-Users

Magic-users start with 1 first level spell at 1st level, 2 at 2nd and 3rd, then 3 for 3 levels, 4 for 4 levels, and so on (as in the chart). The number of spells increases the same for each spell level. Magic-users can cast another level of spells at every odd numbered level.

Cleric's Turning

The only table in the whole lot that makes any sense. At higher levels, clerics can turn the next undead monster at every level, getting better by 2 pips. At 4th level they automatically destroy the weakest sort.

Thief's Abilities

Thieves add 5% to each ability (except Climbing and Hearing) per level up to 99% (highest). Climbing adds 1% each level, and the range to hear noise goes up 1 every 4 levels. Thief's blow from behind ability gives them triple damage at levels 5-8, x4 at 9-12, x5 at 13-16, and so on. Thieves can read languages 80% of the time at 4th level, like in Basic, but they can’t read magic scrolls (not cleric) until 10th level.

Attack Matrices

Characters Attacking

I did these tables a little different from the book because I wanted to make a smooth transition from level to level without jumping from e.g. 19 to 17, like a fighter does from level 3 to 4 in the old rules. If you look at the average level for each range (which is how they did it in the old rules--completely nuts!), it works out to about the same without any jumps.

1st level characters need a 20 to hit a monster with a 0 AC. The fighter's chance to hit goes up 1 (3/3) every level. The cleric's goes up 3/4 of a point, drop the fraction, thief 3/5, and magic-user 3/6 (or 1/2) per level. Did you see the math magic I did there?

Monsters Attacking

Same as 1st level characters, monsters with less than 1 Hit Dice need a 20 to hit 0 AC, then the number to hit goes down 1 per HD. So, 1 HD needs 19, 2 an 18, 3 a 17, and so on. Monsters with HD+n are counted as the next higher HD.

Saves

I cast some math magic on the saving throw tables too. For each save I averaged the total increase from level 1 to 13 from the Saving Throw matrix in D&D and spread it out over the levels. For instance, fighters save Death Ray 12 at 1st level and 4 at 13+. Formula, where L is character level: 12-(12-4)/(13-1)*(L-1). So the saving throw goes down 2/3rds point per level, rounding up. Clerics also go over 12 levels too, but I used 10 as the divisor for magic-users.

Fighters have the best saves, total increase 8 over 12, except dragon breath, which is 10/12. Clerics' good saves are 8/12 (Spells, Death Ray), others are 7/12. Magic-users have the worst. Their spells (good) save is 7/10; the rest are only 5/10.

Basic D&D says Thieves save as fighters, but Greyhawk has them as M-Us. I took a road across the middle ground. Thieves start like fighters in all categories, and they progress as fighters in physical categories (8 and 10 over 12) and as M-Us against spells and wands (7, 5/10).

Elves, dwarves, and halflings use the best save in each category by their class (multi-class possible), like dual-classed humans. Dwarves and halflings get +2 to all saves except dragon breath, which gets a +1.

Paradigm Lost #2 (November 1980)

Experience Points by Class and Level [E]

LevelThiefClericFighterMagic-User
10000
21,2001,5002,0002,500
32,4003,0004,0005,000
44,8006,0008,00010,000
59,60012,00016,00020,000
619,20024,00032,00040,000
738,40048,00064,00080,000
876,80096,000128,000160,000
9153,600192,000256,000320,000
10230,400288,000384,000480,000
11307,200384,000512,000640,000
12384,000480,000640,000800,000
13460,800576,000768,000960,000
14537,600672,000896,0001,120,000
15614,400768,0001,024,0001,280,000
16691,200864,0001,152,0001,440,000

Hit Dice by Class and Level [E]

LevelThiefClericFighterMagic-User
11d41d61d81d4
22d42d62d82d4
33d43d63d83d4
44d44d64d84d4
55d45d65d85d4
66d46d66d86d4
77d47d67d87d4
88d48d68d88d4
99d49d69d89d4
109d4+19d6+19d8+29d4+1
119d4+29d6+29d8+49d4+2
129d4+39d6+39d8+69d4+3
139d4+49d6+49d8+89d4+4
149d4+59d6+59d8+109d4+5
159d4+69d6+69d8+129d4+6
169d4+79d6+79d8+149d4+7

Number of Spells per Day [E]

Clerics

Spell Level —
Level1st2nd3rd4th5th6th7th
1
21
32
421
5321
63221
743221
843222
9543221
10543322
11653332
126543321
137644322
147644432
158754432
168755432
179855533
189865543

Magic-Users

Spell Level —
Level1st2nd3rd4th5th6th7th8th9th
11
22
321
432
5321
6332
74321
84332
944321
1044332
11544321
12544332
135544321
145544332
1555544321
1665544332
17655544321
18665544332

Cleric’s Turning [E]

Undead Monster —
LevelSkeletonZombieGhoulWightWraithMummySpectreVampire
17911NNNNN
2T7911NNNN
3TT7911NNN
4DTT7911NN
5DDTT7911N
6DDDTT7911
7DDDDTT79
8DDDDDTT7
9DDDDDDTT
10DDDDDDDT
11DDDDDDDD
N: No effect
T: Automatic turn
D: Automatic destroy

Thief’s Abilities [E]

LevelOpen
Lock
(%)
Remove
Trap
(%)
Pick
Pocket
(%)
Move
Silently
(%)
Hide in
Shadows
(%)
Climb
Sheer
Surfaces
(%)
Hear
Noise
(d6)
1*1510202010872
22015252515882
32520303020893
4**3025353525903
5*3530404030913
64035454535923
74540505040934
85045555545944
9*5550606050954
10***6055656555964
116560707060975
127065757565985
13*7570808070995
148075858575995
158580909080995
169085959585995
17*9590999990995
189999999995995
199999999999995
* Blow from behind (+4 attack) starts at ×2 damage, increases every 4 levels to ×3, ×4, and so on
** Read languages 80%
*** Read magic scrolls

Character Attack Matrices [E]

Fighter Attacking

Character Level —
AC12345678910111213141516
0201918171615141312111098765
119181716151413121110987654
21817161514131211109876543
3171615141312111098765432
416151413121110987654322
51514131211109876543222
6141312111098765432222
713121110987654322222
81211109876543222222
9111098765432222222

Cleric Attacking

Character Level —
AC12345678910111213141516
02020191817171615141413121111109
1191918171616151413131211101098
21818171615151413121211109987
3171716151414131211111098876
416161514131312111010987765
5151514131212111099876654
614141312111110988765543
71313121110109877654432
812121110998766543322
91111109887655432222

Thief Attacking

Character Level —
AC12345678910111213141516
020201919181717161615141413131211
119191818171616151514131312121110
21818171716151514141312121111109
3171716161514141313121111101098
41616151514131312121110109987
515151414131212111110998876
61414131312111110109887765
713131212111010998776654
8121211111099887665543
911111010988776554432

Magic-User Attacking

Character Level —
AC12345678910111213141516
020201919181817171616151514141313
119191818171716161515141413131212
218181717161615151414131312121111
317171616151514141313121211111010
4161615151414131312121111101099
51515141413131212111110109988
614141313121211111010998877
7131312121111101099887766
81212111110109988776655
911111010998877665544

Monster Attack Matrix [E]

Monster Hit Dice —
AC<1123456789101112131415
0201918171615141312111098765
119181716151413121110987654
21817161514131211109876543
3171615141312111098765432
416151413121110987654322
51514131211109876543222
6141312111098765432222
713121110987654322222
81211109876543222222
9111098765432222222

Saving Throws [E]

Fighters

Character Level —
Save12345678910111213141516
Spell
Magic Staff
161615141413121211101098876
Magic Wand1313121111109987765543
Death Ray
Poison
121211101098876654432
Turn to Stone141413121211101098876654
Dragon Breath151514131211101098765543

Clerics

Character Level —
Save12345678910111213141516
Spell
Magic Staff
1515141313121111109987765
Magic Wand1212111110109887765544
Death Ray
Poison
1111109987765543322
Turn to Stone1414131312121110109987766
Dragon Breath161615141413121211101098876

Magic-Users

Character Level —
Save12345678910111213141516
Spell
Magic Staff
1515141313121111109887665
Magic Wand14141313121211111010998877
Death Ray
Poison
131312121111101099887766
Turn to Stone131312121111101099887766
Dragon Breath161615151414131312121111101099

Thieves

Character Level —
Save12345678910111213141516
Spell
Magic Staff
16161514141312121110998776
Magic Wand131312121111101099887766
Death Ray
Poison
121211101098876654432
Turn to Stone141413121211101098876654
Dragon Breath151514131211101098765543

Multi- and Dual-Class Characters [E]

Multi-class (non-human) and dual-class (human) characters use the best save for each category by class.

Dwarves and Halflings [E]

Dwarves and halflings add 2 to the dice roll to all saves except Dragon Breath, to which they add 1.

This Post Has 4 Comments

  1. Davoid

    As it’s a thoroughly beaten dead horse, I will not comment more than to express my appreciation of Hazard’s rant about the cluster-kludge that the rules became over time.

Leave a Reply